Islamic Perspective: Are Digital Currencies Permissible Under Shariah Law?

Islamic Perspective: Are Digital Currencies Permissible Under Shariah Law?

03.02.2023
Author: Robert Strickland
Subscribe

 

Islamic banking and financial regulations have established specific guidelines. The rise of digital currencies has naturally drawn attention from Islamic scholars and practitioners. This piece explores the compatibility of cryptocurrencies with Islamic principles and their status under Sharia law.

ARE DIGITAL CURRENCIES ACCEPTABLE IN ISLAMIC PRACTICE?

Sharia texts indicate two main concerns with cryptocurrencies:

  • Transaction anonymity, which falls under the concept of gharar (uncertainty). The anonymous nature of digital currency transfers means participants cannot identify each other.
  • Significant volatility, which relates to maysir (gambling-like behavior). The extreme price fluctuations and associated risks of cryptocurrencies make them comparable to gambling activities.

Islamic tradition also maintains that currency issuance should be a state function. However, Sharia law hasn't explicitly banned digital currencies.

ISLAMIC CURRENCY REQUIREMENTS

Sharia law outlines several key currency criteria:

  • Physical presence or verifiable existence. Valid currencies must be tangible or demonstrably real, with stable values unlike Bitcoin's dramatic fluctuations. Traditionally, Islam recognizes value in physical commodities like precious metals and essential goods.
  • Limited availability. Items easily obtained or generated aren't considered valid currency. Therefore, computer-mined cryptocurrencies fail to meet Islamic standards.
  • Government oversight. Currency management, including circulation and stability measures, should be under state control. These requirements make it difficult to justify cryptocurrencies under Islamic law, despite the absence of explicit prohibitions.

A notable development is Tatarstan's halal cryptocurrency, itcoin, backed by cattle meat (10 kg per coin), aligning with Islamic requirements for natural asset backing.

DIVERSE PERSPECTIVES IN THE MUSLIM COMMUNITY

Views on cryptocurrency acceptance vary within the Muslim community. Blossom Finance founder Matthew Martin, a Muslim, considers Bitcoin halal, citing its mathematical and programming foundations as legitimate security.

However, Turkish religious authorities oppose cryptocurrencies, viewing them as incompatible with Islamic principles due to their speculative nature and lack of government oversight.

Other instructions

Securing Your Crypto: A Deep Dive into Cold and Hot Wallet Creation
Beyond Bitcoin: Exploring Shamir's Secret Sharing in Cryptocurrency Security
Blockchain Evolution: A 30-Year Projection by the Reputation Institute
Worldcoin's Global Vision: Sam Altman's Ambitious Plan to Create Earth's First Human Registry
Understanding TVL: The Key Performance Metric in DeFi Ecosystems
Lightning Network: The Game-Changing Solution to Bitcoin's Scalability Challenge